Peloton Bike+ vs Schwinn IC4
Critics score the Peloton Bike+ 84 and the Schwinn IC4 86 out of 100, from 13 and 8 professional reviews. 5 outlets reviewed both: 1 scored the Peloton Bike+ higher, 3 scored the Schwinn IC4 higher and 1 gave both the same score. On average those critics put the Schwinn IC4 2 points ahead.
Image: PelotonPeloton Bike+
Praised for: workout features (13 of 13), build quality (2 of 13), ease of use (2 of 13)
Criticised for: price (12 of 13), subscription costs (9 of 13)
The catch: It is expensive, and a paid subscription is required.
All 13 reviews of the Peloton Bike+ →
We earn a commission if you buy through these links. It never changes a score.
Image: SchwinnSchwinn IC4
Praised for: workout features (8 of 8), build quality (3 of 8)
The catch: The console display is small and basic.
All 8 reviews of the Schwinn IC4 →
We earn a commission if you buy through these links. It never changes a score.
Critics who reviewed both
The fairest comparison: the same reviewer, the same standards| Outlet | Peloton Bike+ | Schwinn IC4 | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| CNET | 78 | 83est. | -5 |
| Garage Gym Reviews | 86 | 90 | -4 |
| Good Housekeeping | 83est. | 85est. | -2 |
| Runner's World | 83est. | 83est. | same |
| T3 | 92est. | 89est. | +3 |
Scores converted to 0–100. Difference is the Peloton Bike+ minus the Schwinn IC4. Outlined tiles are estimated from the verdict. Each score links to the review.
Compare either one with another exercise bike → · All exercise bikes ranked →
Common questions
Which is better, the Peloton Bike+ or the Schwinn IC4?
Critics rate the Schwinn IC4 higher: 86 against 84. 5 outlets reviewed both: 1 scored the Peloton Bike+ higher, 3 scored the Schwinn IC4 higher and 1 gave both the same score. On average those critics put the Schwinn IC4 2 points ahead.
Do critics agree about the Peloton Bike+ and the Schwinn IC4?
The Peloton Bike+: broad agreement, scores from 77 to 92. The Schwinn IC4: critics agree, scores from 83 to 90.