Breast pumps, ranked by critic score
2 ranked by critic score · 4 more not yet ranked · 13 professional reviews
Breast pumps, judged on comfort, suction and portability.
Image: WillowWillow Go
4 professional reviewers tested the Willow Go, and 4 recommend it. Most praised: comfort and easy to use.
The catch: It has many small parts to clean and can spill when full.
Early score: only 4 professional reviews so far. Expect it to move as more reviews come in.
3 of these 4 outlets print no score. We estimated theirs from the review text, then adjusted the estimates against the ratings outlets actually print (ours ran slightly low). An estimate is never higher than 92.
We earn a commission if you buy through these links. It never changes a score.
Of the 2 breast pumps we score so far, the highest-rated by professional reviewers is the Willow Go: critic score 84 out of 100 from 4 reviews, 4 of them positive. Most praised: comfort and easy to use.
Early reads · 4 not yet ranked
Not ranked, listed A to Z. We publish a critic score once at least 4 professional reviews of the exact model exist; with 2 or 3 we show a provisional average.
- Medela Pump in Style with MaxFlow · 1 review so far (BabyGearLab: 65)
- Momcozy M5 · no professional reviews yet
- Spectra S1 Plus · provisional 82 from 2 reviews
- Spectra S2 Plus · 1 review so far (BabyGearLab: 74)
Common questions
Which breast pump do critics rate highest?
Of the 2 we score, the Willow Go, with a critic score of 84 from 4 professional reviews. Most praised: comfort and easy to use.
Willow Go vs Elvie Pump: which is better?
Critics score the Willow Go 84 and the Elvie Pump 76. We list the Elvie Pump under “Best for pumping on the go”. Its main drawback: the app's milk volume readings are inaccurate.
Which breast pumps do critics disagree on?
The Elvie Pump (scores from 50 to 89).