Comforters, ranked by critic score
2 ranked by critic score · 4 more not yet ranked · 18 professional reviews
Comforters and duvets, judged on warmth, weight and washability.
Image: BrooklinenBrooklinen All-Season Down Comforter
6 professional reviewers tested the Brooklinen All-Season Down Comforter, and 6 recommend it. Most praised: cooling and build quality. Most common complaint: runs hot.
The catch: Pricey, and care is limited to spot or dry cleaning.
5 of these 6 outlets print no score. We estimated theirs from the review text, then adjusted the estimates against the ratings outlets actually print (ours ran slightly low). An estimate is never higher than 92.
We earn a commission if you buy through these links. It never changes a score.
Of the 2 comforters we score so far, the highest-rated by professional reviewers is the Brooklinen All-Season Down Comforter: critic score 87 out of 100 from 6 reviews, 6 of them positive. Most praised: cooling and build quality. Most common complaint: runs hot.
Early reads · 4 not yet ranked
Not ranked, listed A to Z. We publish a critic score once at least 4 professional reviews of the exact model exist; with 2 or 3 we show a provisional average.
- Bedsure Down Alternative Comforter · 1 review so far (Good Housekeeping: 83 est.)
- Buffy Breeze Comforter · provisional 84 from 3 reviews
- Parachute Down Duvet Insert · no professional reviews yet
- Rest Evercool Cooling Comforter · provisional 89 from 2 reviews
Common questions
Which comforter do critics rate highest?
Of the 2 we score, the Brooklinen All-Season Down Comforter, with a critic score of 87 from 6 professional reviews. Most praised: cooling and build quality. Most common complaint: runs hot.
Brooklinen All-Season Down Comforter vs Buffy Cloud Comforter: which is better?
Critics score the Brooklinen All-Season Down Comforter 87 and the Buffy Cloud Comforter 84. We list the Buffy Cloud Comforter under “Best eco-friendly pick”. Its main drawback: hard to wash, and it runs warm for some sleepers.